Fans fear that the live-action adaptation of Masters of the Universe will be too similar to the John Carter film
An earthly hero in fantasy worlds
Both films share a common narrative axis: a protagonist initially unaware of his true identity who is transported to an alien world, where he must accept his fate and save his new home.
In John Carterthe main character, played by Taylor Kitsch, is a veteran of the American Civil War who, tired of the conflict, ends up on the planet Barsoom (Mars). There he discovers unique abilities and is drawn into a war that forces him to rediscover his purpose.
On the other hand, inside Masters of the universeNicholas Galitzine will play Adam, a young Earthman trapped in a mundane job. Unbeknownst to him, Adam is the lost prince of Eternia. Everything changes when he finds the Sword of Power, which transports him to his home world, where he will face the evil Skeletor, played by Jared Leto.
Reluctant heroes and worlds in danger
The basic premise of both stories revolves around the hero’s journey. However, while John Carter explored the deserts of Mars and its tribal conflicts, Masters of the universe bet on an Eternia full of magic, science fiction and epic battles. Despite these aesthetic differences, the plot seems to follow the same steps, which has caused concern among hardcore fans.
One of the most controversial decisions of the new Masters of the universe it’s their choice to set much of the story on Earth. Adam is presented as an ordinary man, far from the majesty of Eternia, which has drawn criticism for simplifying a rich and fantastic mythology.
Fans of the classic series remember He-Man and the Masters of the Universe as a colorful epic, full of unique characters and conflicts that mix technology and magic. Reducing this to a beginning on Earth, with Adam trapped in the monotony of an office job, feels like a departure from the essence of the franchise.
The weight of nostalgia and secondary characters
One of the major attractions of Masters of the universe it’s its large cast of iconic characters. Teela (Camila Mendes), Evil-Lyn (Alison Brie) and Man-At-Arms (Idris Elba) are crucial figures who could add depth and charisma to the film. However, many fear that its potential will be obscured by excessive attention to the earthly history of Adam.
Director Travis Knight, known for hits such as Hornet Yes Kubo and the two magic stringsit has the ability to combine emotion and spectacle. This could work in the film’s favor, as long as it manages to balance nostalgia with new narrative elements.
Will John Carter’s fate repeat itself?
The case of John Carter serves as a warning. Despite being based on a literary work that inspired sagas such as Star Wars Yes Avatarsthe film was criticized for feeling derivative and failing to connect with audiences.
TO Masters of the universethe challenge lies in not falling into the trap of being perceived as a simple copy. The decision to emphasize Earth could alienate longtime fans who were hoping for an epic journey to Eternia.
However, if the script, performances and direction can capture the essence of the saga, there is a chance that this reinvention will exceed expectations.
The importance of respecting the essence
The success of Masters of the universe It will depend on how it handles the central themes of identity, destiny and heroism without losing what makes this franchise unique. Although the parallels with John Carter are evident, there’s room for this adaptation to shine if it manages to celebrate and expand Eternia’s rich mythology.
For fans who grew up watching the animated series, this film has the potential to be a love letter to their childhood… or a monumental disappointment. The balance is in the hands of the creative team.