Find out why Obi-Wan Kenobi resorted to violence to teach Luke Skywalker in an epic scene in Saiga.
In the year Star Wars fans have learned a lot about the Jedi Order since its debut in George Lucas’ galaxy in 1977. They were warrior monks who were mystical in nature. Committed to peace and protection, they are known for following the light side of the Force, following violence as a last resort. But then why did Obi-Wan Kenobi use Ponda Baba’s arm in “Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope” to upset Luke Skywalker?
The importance of excessive action
In Mos Isley’s cantina, Obi-Wan overturns Ponda Baba, a moment that serves to show the fear and respect that a Jedi weapon inspires. However, in retrospect, it seems a disproportionate response. At the end of the original trilogy, there is enough subtext in the story to explain this action.
Luke Skywalker, eager for adventure, agrees to take Obi-Wan Kenobi, C3PO, and R2-D2 to the spaceport to reach Alderaan. He is not ready to face the galaxy as a whole, let alone violence. At the cantina, Luke tries to get the waiter’s attention, when Ponda Baba and Dr. Evazan collide. Obi-Wan first tries a peaceful solution, offering to buy a drink. But the situation is getting worse.
At this point, Obi-Wan has been tracking Luke for 19 years. Their mission was not only to protect Anakin Skywalker’s son, but also to train him in the ways of the Force to confront his father and the Emperor. So, what Obi-Wan sees in the cantina is not the Padawan, but the young man he has waited for a third of his life.
The Jedi Master and his inner turmoil
Outside of work, there is an emotional dimension to the Jedi Master’s actions. Darth Vader has no idea what he knows about Leia, Luke or their relationship. Kenobi’s response is to remove the threat quickly and surely. Although only Panda Baba’s arm is separated, this action is extended in the “Star Wars” comic series, Aqualish appears instead of cybernetic.
Obi-Wan’s role in “A New Hope” is to introduce Luke to this world, which is reflected in Alec Guinness’s performance. Despite his calmness, this great Jedi feared for Luke’s future and chances of success. The end of “Obi-Wan Kenobi” shows his ability to face his fears and doubts, Reva, also known as the third sister, helps him return from the dark side. However, he shows some reluctance when training Luke, unlike his direct approach with Anakin and Ahsoka Tano.
Kenobi’s sacrifice and the final lesson
In his final confrontation with Darth Vader on the Death Star, Obi-Wan chose to unite with the Force, possibly sending Luke away for a better teacher, Yoda. He knew he would continue in his power, less limited by his fear and attachment to the mortal plane.
The story of Star Wars has always been told in a fragmented way. The character’s actions in the cantina, although initially for cinematographic reasons, are integrated into an increasingly rich overarching narrative. Even though the series doesn’t really hold together, it’s not necessarily a bad piece of writing. In “A New Hope” Jedi’s actions are not out of character, and there were many hints about his mental state at the time.
“Star Wars: A New Hope” is available on Blu-ray, DVD and digital, and can be streamed via Disney+.