The universe of Star Trek It survived for 60 years with ups and downs, from the greatest successes to the less remembered moments, but section 31 seems to have touched the bottom
A new failed attempt in the saga?
Star Trek: Section 31 It started as a series in 2019, but after several years of development, Paramount decided that it would finally become a film for its streaming platform. Yeoh, who plays Philippa Georgiou, a well -known character of Star Trek: the discoveryjoins the secret group of the star fleet, Section 31In a crucial mission. The premise seems promising, but according to experts, execution is a disaster.
Although some reviews, such as that of The limitthey describe it as “fun enough” and /Movie He gives him the title of “B Trash” (but with a certain charm), most of the critics consider him a total failure. For many, this film represents the “worst thing” that has ever brought this name Star Trek.
Unanimous judgments of experts
If you examine the most relevant reviews, opinions agree on this Star Trek: Section 31 He has nothing to do with the spirit of the franchise. Daniel Cooper, of Dedicate onselfHe defines it “the worst thing that has ever brought the name”. Star Trek throughout the memory. Jeannette Catsoulis, from The New York TimesIt describes the film as “a chaos of unexpected twists and turns and explanatory dialogues”, while Jordan Hoffman of Ignensures that his reaction is simple: “It is not Star Trek“.
Fans and critics stressed that, despite Michelle Yeoh’s great name, not even his presence can save the film from mediocrity. According to Frank Scheck, The Hollywood journalist“Not even Michelle Yeoh can save this by -product.” Also, James Whitbrook by io9 underlines that it is “a mediocre action film, and even worse Star Trek“.
A useless turning point
What started as a project that promised to expand the universe of Star Trek It has become a film that seems to not understand what makes the saga special. Instead of a profound exploration of his characters and his philosophy, Section 31 It seems to remain a simple action film, without a soul or meaning in the context of the series.
Alex Perry, de Trekcoregoes further, stating that this is “the greatest disappointment of the Kurtzman era”, the executive producer of the last series of Star TrekWhile Clint Worthington, from Rogerebert.comCompare the movie with Rebellious moona work that clearly does not know why fans look at her Star Trek First of all.
The future of Star Trek and paramount+
Despite the avalanche of negative reviews, Paramount will be likely to continue betting on several content Star Trek. The franchise had its ups and downs, but remains one of the most loved by fans of science fiction. Fortunately, there are other series such as Strange new worldswho have renewed hope among followers, demonstrating it Star Trek It still has a lot to offer.
If you are a fan of Star Trek, Section 31 It could be a movie to watch out of curiosity, but judging by the reviews better not to expect too much. Will this be the end of an era or just another setback in the history of this iconic franchise?