The Rohirrim War, the new animated epic from Warner Bros. set in the universe created by Tolkien, divides opinions among fans
A long-awaited return to Rohan
Set 183 years earlier of the events narrated in the original trilogy, The Rohirrim War It focuses on the figure of Helm Hammerhand, the legendary king of Rohan. The story tells of how Helm and his people resist the brutal attack of the ruthless Wulf, a lord of Dunlending seeking revenge. At the center of the plot is Héra, Helm’s daughter, who takes on a crucial role in leading the resistance during the siege of the fortress that will later be known as Helm’s Deep.
A gem or a disappointment?
The initial reactions present a diverse picture:
- Rama’s screen He emphasized that the film is “epic, grand and captivating”, with anime-style animation that evokes nostalgia for returning to Middle-earth. “One of my favorite films of the year,” he concludes.
- Mike Reyes He called it “an impressive foray into anime for the Middle-earth saga,” praising its ability to capture Tolkien’s epic essence.
- However, not everyone shares this enthusiasm. Shahbaz noted that its “long running time” and “unexciting story” make it difficult to connect with the film, while Ezra Cubero He complained about a “lack of surprise” in the script and a “lethargic” pace that left him dissatisfied.
On the one hand, many praise the Exquisite animation and the epic battles. On the other hand, some criticize that, despite the potential of the anime medium, the film fails to fully explore the character of its protagonists.
A luxury cast and a creative team
Behind this ambitious project there is Kenji Kamiyamadirector known for his work on Blade Runner: Black Lotus Yes Ghost in the shell. Screenwriter Philippa Boyens, a veteran of film adaptations of the lord of the rings Yes the hobbitassures that the anime format “is perfect for character-driven stories, something that fits the Japanese storytelling style wonderfully.”
Among the voices that bring the characters to life, the following stand out:
- Brian Cox like Helm Hammerhand,
- Gaia Saggia like his name,
- Luke Pasqualino like Wulf,
and a cast that includes recognized names like Shaun Dooley (The witcher) Yes Jude Akuwudike (Beasts without a nation).
The production team also includes illustrious names such as Peter Jackson Yes Fran Walshwho return as executive producers.
An unexpected heroine in the heart of Rohan
The character of His namedaughter of Helm Hammerhand, emerges as a key figure in the history of The Rohirrim War. Thanks to her courage and determination, Héra takes unexpected leadership in the midst of chaos. His role as a leader of the resistance highlights the power of female characters into Tolkien’s universe, offering a fresh and inspiring perspective. In a world dominated by warriors and military strategies, Héra demonstrates that courage does not depend on gender, but on inner strength and the will to protect those close to us.
The film also takes the opportunity to explore the roots of Helm’s Deepone of the most iconic fortresses in Middle-earth. This enclave, immortalized in The two towerstakes on a richer and deeper dimension thanks to the story of the sacrifices and alliances that have made it an impregnable bulwark against the forces of evil.
A risky bet?
One of the most debated points is the decision to use anime to tell a story about Middle Earth. For some, this choice brings freshness and endless visual possibilities. For others, it is a wasted approach to focus on a story that is “less magical” than other parts of Tolkien’s legendary world.
Despite the criticism, The Rohirrim War offers an in-depth look at Rohan’s legacy, featuring exciting cameos and a richer exploration of the tradition which will fascinate the most loyal followers.
The Rohirrim War hits theaters today December 5, 2024.