THE Star Trek The franchise is one of the most popular and far-reaching media empires of all time, but not every effort has been an instant success. Twenty years ago, Star Trek took a gamble and lost with a prequel-sequel TV series, Star Trek: Business. Four decades ago BusinessAfter the surprising failure, in the 1960s, Gene Roddenberry single-handedly influenced the genre of science fiction that people love and enjoy. In 1964, Roddenberry submitted his first draft of what became Star Trek for consideration; Star Trek: The Original Series debuted in 1966 and made history.
Star Trek has reached every corner of popular culture and media over the years, and for good reason. Even though the very first reviews of Roddenberry’s show weren’t five stars, it didn’t take long for the show’s innovative inventions, gripping storyline, interesting characters, and magnificent world-building to capture everyone’s attention. At the end of The original series by 1969, everyone, even those who had never seen the series, knew the concept. Although numerous sequels and spin-offs have been commissioned and continued over the years, unfortunately, Star Trek: Enterprise remains at the bottom of the barrel.
Where Star Trek: Enterprise fits into the franchise
It is no secret that the Star Trek the franchise is huge in terms of scale, installments and popularity. Over six decades, the franchise has expanded from a single television series to virtually every medium available; in total there are six films in the Original seriesthree in the New generationand three in the Star Trek restart; Article 31a television film, was released on January 24, 2025. Comics, documentaries, unpublished projects, games, novels, reference works, audiobooks: at this stage, there is no area of popular culture and the arts that Star Trek had no impact on.
In terms of production, Star Trek: Enterprise is the sixth Star Trek television series made and the final television series released via broadcast. Created by Rick Berman and Brannon Braga, Business followed his two predecessors, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine (1933-1999) and Star Trek: Voyager (1995-2001). Berman and Braga have already been approached Travelerand asked to create a new spin-off series to continue the Star Trek franchise. While Business is the last series broadcast, there have been six subsequent series Star Trek series; the most recent, Strange new worldsdebuted in 2022 and still runs for three seasons.
For those looking to watch the entirety Star Trek franchise in chronological order, Star Trek: Enterprise is the first to light up. The events of Business spans a century and serves as a prequel to Star Trek: The Original Series and his successors, from 2151 to 2161; for reference, The original series takes place between 2266 and 2269. As the title of the series suggests, Business revolves around the Businessthe first Earth ship capable of traveling to warp five. During the four seasons of the series, the team led by Archer (Scott Bakula), T’Pol (Jolene Blalock) and Trip (Conner Trinneer) and their subordinates travel the galaxy, where they come into contact with different alien species.
Star Trek: Enterprise was a victim of inconsistent writing
Star Trek: Enterprise found itself in an interesting position when it premiered in 2001. Between Star Trekthe unprecedented level of popularity and the number of television series that preceded it, BusinessThe writers and production team had to figure out not only how to capture attention with a new story, but also how to please long-term fans with new viewers. While the first two seasons of Star Trek The prequels were generally well received, there is no doubt that in retrospect the series suffered from inconsistent writing across the board, in almost every aspect. Since the prequel was made after the main events of Star Trek: The Original Series, the general atmosphere and technological changes were in themselves quite noticeable; the Ebusiness itself, for example, arguably looked more modern than the original NCC-1701.
The slight inconsistencies in setting construction are incredibly minor compared to the actual plots presented throughout. Star Trek: Enterprise. The overall story arc and most of the subsequent B-plots had potential, but ultimately came off as boring and uninteresting. Whether it’s an attempt to build on what already existed before or a decision to pivot to try new materials, the majority of Star Trek: Enterprise, Seasons 1 and 2 felt redundant and recycled. When something original was used for the series, the inclusions were promising, but were either inconsistently inserted or misused, such as the emergence of transporters, cloaking devices, and the antagonistic Borg.
In keeping with the overall boring plots, the overall dialogue throughout Star Trek: Enterprise leaves a lot to be desired, a fact that is becoming more and more prevalent as time goes on. Successful dialogue on television depends on a variety of factors, such as natural cadence, appropriate responses, and specific intent. Throughout Star Trek: Enterprisenone of these vital characteristics of good dialogue ever really surface. Archer, T’Pol, and Trip joke and converse like any other crew, for example, but their conversations often have a blatantly unnatural rhythm. When the series tries to reconcile the Star Trek canon with new developments, dialogue and explanations also tend to fall apart, as timelines, ideas and discussions usually don’t line up and have a distinct choppy sound.
Star Trek: Enterprise characters were not developed
THE Star Trek The franchise has featured hundreds of characters over the years, with many protagonists including Star Trek: The Original Seriesstill widely recognized, appreciated and discussed by fans and non-fans alike. Captain James T. Kirk, Spock, and Dr. Leonard “Bones” McCoy from the first series remain an iconic trio due to their complementary personalities and dynamic relationships with each other. Other dimension Star Trek Characters who have stolen the spotlight and fans’ hearts over time include Jean-Luc Picard, Worf, and Nyota Uhura.
All these popular Star Trek the characters share a plethora of core values, external and internal conflicts that raise the stakes, and a knack for problem-solving, which fans have regularly found engaging and worth supporting. Unfortunately, the crew showed up on Star Trek: Enterprise never carried the same emotional weight, leading to a glaring lack of development across the board. Archer, T’Pol, and Trip had their own personalities throughout the series, but there never came a point where true authenticity and natural chemistry, like the main three Original series characters, seemed completely believable. Another character in Business who looked very and particularly underdeveloped was Travis Mayweather. Travis is identified as a “baby boomer” early in the series, but his background is never fully explored, only rarely mentioned.
The main characters featured throughout Star Trek Enterprise were not only underdeveloped, but also generally underutilized. Several characters were introduced with significant gifts or interesting talents, but these talents never materialized on screen or were rarely used despite their supposed importance. Hoshi Sato, for example, was the Business communications officer and could speak 40 languages; Hoshi also had an intriguing history that included a period of illegal poker. Hoshi’s character, however, was largely sidelined until the series’ final season. Despite her language skills, Hoshi was never promoted either.
Star Trek: Enterprise brought nothing new to the table
As a prequel, it was essential for Star Trek: Enterprise to capitalize on Star Trek the knowledge and information that already existed; new ideas and additional characters outside of the already established canon were fine in theory for this series, but ended up being poor in execution. Inconsistent writing and underdeveloped characters were one thing, but a massive failure that pushed Star Trek: Enterprise into unsalvageable territory was his lack of fan consideration and engagement. At the time, for example, Star Trek fans were invested in the Earth-Romulan War, first introduced in Star Trek: The Original Series, and I thought Business would revolve around this conflict. Instead, the series introduced Xindi, which left people disappointed and frustrated.
Many other examples show how Star Trek: Enterprise failed to expand on the franchise’s canon, instead trying to create something new. Until the fourth season, for example, Vulcans were portrayed as illogical and generally hypocritical. However, the Vulcans in Star Trek: The Original Series are characterized as being logical and level-headed. The Temporal Cold War also had a limited impact on Star Trek fans because of how the associated time travel was used and how the conflict was inserted into the overall narrative.
In all, Star Trek: Enterprise was a massive failure and the weakest Star Trek disbursement due to a combination of factors – some intentional or chosen, while others were involuntary. By time Business arrived, the franchise had six television shows with back-to-back premieres, which created a feeling of fatigue among some fans. Compared to massive networks like NBC and CBS, UPN doesn’t carry the same clout. Add in an inconsistent release schedule and an unnecessary theme song change to the entire issues, and in the end, it’s no wonder Star Trek: Enterprise fell on his face.
- Release date
-
2005 – 2004
- Showrunner
-
Brannon Braga
- Directors
-
Brannon Braga
- Writers
-
Brannon Braga
